Posted by
Buckeye McFrog on Tuesday, July 11, 2006 3:13:00 PM
It is one of those stories that gets passed around annually at each holiday gathering, gets told and retold again, and eventually makes its way into the annals of family lore.
It was the late 1980’s, and my brother-in-law was playing with a local Hair Band on a college campus in America’s heartland. He and his band-mates, clad in long and shaggy, mullet-style manes, accented generously with Spandex, would play the local bars and hangouts on weekends, covering tunes from all of the chart-topping mega-Hair-Bands of the day…..Van Halen, the Scorpions, Night Ranger, Poison…..and of course, the ultimate hot-rotation rock-and-roll band of that era, Bon Jovi.
As he tells the story, late one Friday evening, a self-appointed music critic at the bar, (who had been there too long and had had a few too many), decided to give a more demonstrative expression of his feelings about the band’s performance. After heckling he and his band mates from the bar for some time, with such witty and sardonic expressions as “You Guys ****!”, the inebriated critic eventually decided to approach my brother-in-law and make things a bit more personal.
He walked up to him after the last set, broke directly through his space-bubble and went nose-to-nose with him, continuing to critique his performance in very crude terms. At this point my brother-in-law decided on a gentleman’s response, telling the guy that he was drunk out of his mind and needed to just go away and sleep it off. At this point the critic became enraged. He thumped my brother-in-law hard in the chest several times and glared at him, as if to say “Oh, yeah? Make me!. When this did not elicit the desired response, he persisted in shoving him in the chest repeatedly, and began shouting in a loud and agitated voice, “What’cha gonna do, Bon Jovi?”. (this was intended as a sarcastic dig at the hair and costume that he was wearing at that moment). When my brother-in-law did not immediately fight back, the guy continued to shove him harder and more frequently, repeating for all in the room to hear….
What’ cha gonna do, Bon Jovi?
(shove)
Huh? What’cha gonna do, Bon Jovi?
(shove)
After each round of this there was a pregnant pause, while all in attendance waited anxiously to see just what would happen next. It went on for quite a few rounds. After weighing for some time his chances against a drunken lout nearly twice his size, my brother-in-law decided it was not worth the effort, and simply walked away. After all, it was just a campus bar and some cover tunes, nothing worth spending the next few months in traction over. The incident was quickly consigned to history, along with his music career (and his hair).
My brother-in-law likes to tell this story at family gatherings, perhaps for amusement, perhaps with a wisp of regret that he did not decide differently and take a swing at the guy. For whatever reason, that phrase has ensconced itself in our family’s lexicon, whenever someone is being challenged or dared in an aggressive way….”What’ cha gonna do, Bon Jovi?”
Whether a cousin has just been beaned in a baseball game, or an aunt has just discovered a fraudulent charge on her Visa account, or an uncle has had his house egged by the neighborhood kids, someone in the extended family will invariably say to them, ”What’cha gonna do, Bon Jovi?” as a rhetorical call to action. Everybody knows what it means. My brother-in-law has mixed feelings about this. (his preschooler, after overhearing this story at the adult dinner table, has taken a particular liking to it whenever she is being scolded for testing the limits of parental authority, much to his chagrin).
This story has been much on my mind lately as I’ve watched the Bush Administration and its response to current world events. It seems that every time I look up, the President is again being shoved in the chest by an aggressive bully, getting in his face and shouting, “What’cha gonna do, Bon Jovi?” And, just like everyone in that 80’s bar, America and the world keep watching and waiting anxiously for a response.
The New York Times leaks details of a classified terrorist surveillance program…(shove)!
“What’cha gonna do, Bon Jovi?”
The Times then leaks the details of a highly sensitive, classified program to track terrorist financing….(shove)!
“What’cha gonna do, Bon Jovi?”
The patrons wait for a response…will there be a counter-punch? A prosecution? A Grand Jury? A concrete response of any kind?
Time Magazine brazenly declares on its cover that the Age of Cowboy Diplomacy and the Bush Doctrine are dead…..(shove)!
“What’cha gonna do, Bon Jovi?”
The Supreme Court reverses the US Constitution and 60 years of precedent, and tells the President that he cannot hold tribunals for terror detainees at Gitmo…..(shove)!
“What’cha gonna do, Bon Jovi?”
Now he can’t let that one slide, can he? He’ll have to ignore them, act as Franklin Delano Roosevelt would and proceed with the tribunals anyway, right?
Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, the crazed, apocalyptic leader of Iran, strings along the UN and the World after he ignores deadline after deadline on uranium enrichment.....(Shove)!
“What’cha gonna do, Bon Jovi?”
Kim Jong Il, the loony leader of the North Korean prison state, makes good on his promise to begin firing missiles over his neighbors’ heads, towards a long-fantasized impact in Hawaii…..SHOVE!
“What’cha gonna do, Bon Jovi?”
Ooooh…..he’s just gotta respond to that one, right??
The pregnant pause after each shove just keeps getting longer and longer….leaving one to wonder, are we just waiting for some spectacular, brilliant, yet-to-be-seen-or-believed response to all of this? One that will deliver a sharp comeuppance to all of the bullies in one fell swoop? Or has the President, like a tired band member confronting the drunk at the end of a long performance, just decided he’s had enough, its not worth the aggravation, and it’s time to just walk away?
The problem is…unlike my brother-in-law and his band, President Bush does not have the luxury to walk away from these challenges, or America and the World will enter a dark period of incredible peril. He cannot allow brazen challenges from the partisan press and the courts to undermine his authority to prosecute war, lest all future Presidents find themselves hamstrung under similar circumstances. He cannot let bureaucratic quislings undermine crucial national security programs, just because Rumsfeld or Rice did not give their latest white paper all due consideration. If he does, government ceases to function. He cannot let crazed dictators skip merrily along the nuclear path, lest we wake up some day to find that Yemen is holding our Foreign Policy hostage, while Guatemala has taken out Belize with an ‘H’ bomb.
One of the most admirable and impressive traits of the Bush Presidency has been its fearless resolve to act in the face of great challenges, the Lilliputian efforts of the Press, American Liberals, and the World Community notwithstanding. His bold moves to go after the terrorists in Afghanistan, in Europe, in Miami and Detroit, in chat-rooms and banking parlors, and in settling our long-delayed score with Saddam Hussein, are the stuff John Wayne legends are made of. Instead of celebrating his successes, this seems to have only emboldened his domestic and foreign opponents to start throwing the monkey wrenches with increased vigor. Unfortunately for the President, the stakes in this game have only continued to ratchet upwards, and he simply does not have the luxury of hesitation or vacillation at this critical late hour. As the Iron Lady of Great Britain, Margaret Thatcher, once told his father, “This is no time to go wobbly, George!”
And yet, wobbly is just what he appears to be, and we can only grow more anxious and apprehensive as these provocations continue to pile up without a response. How many more shoves in the chest is he going to take, and how much farther is the bully going to try to push him? The next move is yours, Mr. President. America and the whole world is holding its breath, waiting and watching nervously to see…
“What’cha gonna do, Bon Jovi?”
UPDATE....After putting this post to bed, I've learned that the Bush Administration today has backtracked from their long-held position that Gitmo detainees are not entitled to the protections of the Geneva Convention. They are now going to extend them some of those protections. Arlen Specter is out there saying that it's not enough. This is not looking good!